Julien Duvivier最好的作品之一也是他认为自己所有默片中最喜欢的一部。
Summary
Bullied by his matriarchal mother, abused by his siblings, ignored by his father, Poil de Carotte's childhood is as miserable as it could be. An illegitimate child, he is the main reason for the enmity which exists between his parents, who continue to live together just to keep up appearances. In the end, Poil de Carotte's suffering becomes more than he can bear...
Review
Drawing heavily on the poignant novel by Jules Renard on which it is based, Poil de carotte is a modest yet appealing film which has stood the test of time mainly because of the quality of its acting performances and its inherent humanity. It is more memorable than Julien Duvivier's earlier silent version of 1925, also named Poil de Carotte.
The part of Poil de Carotte was played by 11 year old Robert Lynen, who was alleged to have been discovered whilst walking down the Champs-Elysées in Paris. Lynen is totally captivating and the film made him an instant star, launching what looked like becoming a very promising film career – until he was shot dead whilst fighting against the Germans in 1944. Harry Baur, a legendary stage and film actor (who also died during World War II, allegedly at the hands of the Gestapo), also turns in a typically fine performance. The reconciliation between father and son at the end of the film provides its most enduring image, enough to melt the heart of all but the most stoical of spectators.
@ grand cinema sunshine
这次的案子也不错，虽然起因和结束都稍微有一些突兀，但反射出的内核很喜欢。
更多的是因为对剧版的喜欢，所以会对这部电影抱有兴趣，也因为剧荒的缘故这些年反复看了好几遍第一季和第二季，现在b站就能看剧版的，但电影版自从上映以来就没找到途径看，今天正好机缘巧合的在no视频发现可以看就一口气看完了；看完后感动居多，但也有不小的失望，剧版虽然会有戏剧化的成分，但一般都能做到逻辑自洽，而电影版的收尾该说不说是有些不合理性，甚至说是有些草率的，从全村做局陷害一个好人到最后强行大团圆he，小守当时4岁，难道其间接“杀人”的后果真的比直接间接的带走山本夫妇两条人命还要严重，以至于需要干出这种荒诞的事情？
怎么说呢，挺一般的，不能理解为什么村民要包庇两个四岁的小朋友（第一不是故意的，第二是4岁，因此也不会判刑）把一个大人推出去当凶手判死刑，然后dzjy那个角色前期就是个人型喇叭，跟着主角团到处跑也没啥用，强行加戏，最后认罪演技太差。西岛叔那个角色全程划水，也不知道为什么还要拍个sp营造西岛叔大反派的感觉。总体来说案件设计很离谱，演技尴尬，两星，多一颗给这个系列tv还行
无论是什么笑话由松润的脸说出来都感到可以接受，他独占两星半
熟悉的配方，完全看不出是电影，还以为是sp😂
好看的妹妹在开头都用力出双下巴了 不过妹妹真的头发遮住耳朵很仙气 话说这真的不是搞笑剧嘛 哈哈哈哈 有些对话做的颜艺真的好出戏 哈哈哈
哪里都有西岛叔哈哈哈哈不过还是剧的体量更适合
案件一般吧，这剧不知道还会不会出剧版，电影版就是把该系列露过脸的角色基本都出镜了，也算满足了观众的情怀，说实话我倒觉得当初第一季好看多了。
作为疯魔，你是不是脑瘫啊。
辛苦您了。
全片最爱大概还是奈奈酱回归的那几分钟，第一季真是很经典了耶！
真相不一定能给人带来幸福，但谎言救不了人。
就……强行扯让两个孩子下毒，没有罪犯，happy ending 啦，好无聊啊
已经没有新鲜感了，道枝一出来就知道是凶手了
感觉比sp还是……完整的。冷笑话我开始跟不到了，但那个xxx香草饭？好像很好吃的样子……
一般，开场那个案件太短人物都没分清还特别绕……
哈哈哈一如既往的好看，道具组真的SP超级用心～
这不就是吉高和柄本佑的那个电视剧的故事吗《不知为好》
我还是认为tv的结尾是最佳结尾，给未来留下了无限的可能又点到为止。这个剧场版就是把一切的可能都堵死了，所以我更加坚信有些结局是不适合续写的。退一步说，我从来不是那种强求圆满结局的观众，但是满足于立一个悲剧的框架，过程展开写得极其敷衍的做法真的没必要。编剧仿佛明目张胆地表示其他的不管，就是要写个悲剧让观众哭，我反而内心毫无波动。
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved
